Baseball’s general managers met last week in Las Vegas, and normally that’s the start of the proverbial Hot Stove League. Sure enough, talk of trades and signings predominated, at a function where the groundwork is usually laid for teams to make offseason moves.
Read more Divided appeals court blocks Pentagon from expelling several transgender troops from US military
(And former Dodger Dustin May was an early beneficiary, reaching an agreement on a three-year, $52.5 million deal with the Chicago White Sox that was announced Tuesday.)
This week, the owners meet in New York City. And if you’re waiting for good news out of that meeting, or any assurances that baseball as usual will take place in 2027 … ah, why bother?
What’s worse, the feeling of impending doom or the void borne of uncertainty?
We know this: The collective bargaining agreement between owners and players expires on Dec. 1. Management has announced its intention to begin a lockout on Dec. 2, which basically will halt the business of baseball. The winter meetings, which were scheduled to begin Dec. 11 at the Manchester Grand Hyatt in San Diego, almost certainly will be limited to minor-league business only.
No trades. No signings. No real idea how to proceed, actually, as long as the owners – billionaire owners, might I add – continue to insist on a salary cap through their mouthpiece, Commissioner Rob Manfred.
This is already a battle of wills. The Major League Players Association has consistently and continually resisted the imposition of a salary cap over the years and continues to do so. In early negotiations this time, everything MLB has offered as a sweetener is contingent on acceptance of a cap, and each has been rejected.
Management’s cap proposal would be based on the figure currently used to compute the competitive balance tax for each team. That includes salaries and other benefits, which I’m guessing includes health insurance and the like. And the idea of a 50/50 revenue split as always will come down to how much of it is considered “baseball revenue,” and you can imagine how the interpretations of that figure differ between the sides.
Why are owners so adamant about a cap? The guess here is that the main reason they’re energized doesn’t involve competitive balance, no matter what their “Level The Playing Field” ad campaign implies.
If it did, the Milwaukee Brewers’ World Series championship – with the game’s 19th-largest payroll in 2026 ($144.6 million according to Cot’s Contracts) and its smallest market (a metropolitan area of around 1.69 million) – should have blown that argument out of the water.
No, it is about team valuations. Simply put, baseball owners note that in leagues with caps, teams are estimated to be worth more and sell at a higher price than those in baseball.
Then again, the $3.9 billion that José E. Feliciano and Kwanza Jones paid for the San Diego Padres, and the $4 billion with which Stan Kroenke is purchasing control of the Angels from Arte Moreno, seem to suggest that concern is maybe a wee bit overblown. Before those purchases, the previous record sale price was the $2.4 billion that Steve Cohen paid for the New York Mets in 2020.
Yet, for some strange reason, fans – I’m guessing most of them are working people – seem to be siding with the billionaires in this fight. They’re often the same ones who react negatively every time a Scott Boras client signs a lucrative long-term contract, and in fact many of them begrudge player salaries, period.
Read more Riverside County Sheriff Chad Bianco’s security detail cost $3.19 million, report says
My response: Wouldn’t you want a Scott Boras type negotiating on your behalf?
Or consider it this way: There are 3,428 billionaires in the world, according to Forbes magazine’s count from earlier this year (and I suspect a large portion of that is inherited wealth). In contrast, there are 1,200 men on major-league 40-man rosters, with 780 on 26-man active rosters at any given time. They have a rare skill and are the very best in the world at it. Again, why shouldn’t the very best among them get top dollar?
And don’t bring up ticket prices, please. Those keep going up everywhere, in every sport, regardless of what the home team’s player payroll might be. They won’t be coming back down, either.
So many of those in favor of a cap see certain teams’ payrolls – yes, that of the Dodgers in particular – and seethe because their own favorite teams won’t keep up.
But consider this: The Dodgers in a salary-cap world would still be just fine, because there is no cap on organizational ingenuity. Owners who not only keep their payrolls artificially low but don’t devote any attention or money to player development or scouting? They deserve what they get.
For the true baseball fan, this is awfully depressing. When the sides last had to negotiate a CBA, before the 2022 season, the lockout lasted into spring training before the sides reached an agreement – but a salary cap wasn’t at issue then. Now it’s the dominant issue, if not the sole one.
It’s worth examining the birth of the modern salary cap. In the spring of 1983, the NBA was in peril and assumed to be on the verge of contracting teams. Commissioner Larry O’Brien and Players Association director Larry Fleisher agreed on a modified cap, with a provision that allowed teams to go over the cap to retain their own players.
It might have been intended as a temporary bailout, but it became permanent. And today’s NBA cap is more punitive than ever.
The NFL instituted its cap in 1994, with the players getting free agency restrictions lifted in exchange. And the National Hockey League instituted a cap in the 2005-06 season – but only after Commissioner Gary Bettman canceled the entire 2004-05 season when negotiations with the players stalled.
Is that what we’re looking at here? Then-MLB commissioner Bud Selig wiped out the World Series in 1994 after the players went on strike that August, and a salary cap was part of the discussion in that case. Teams used replacement players the next spring, but federal judge Sonia Sotomayor – now a Supreme Court justice – issued an injunction against the owners on April 2, 1995, to end the 232-day stoppage, resume negotiations and get the regular players back in uniform.
Is there another federal judge out there who might save the 2027 baseball season? Hopefully it doesn’t come to that, but I’m not optimistic.
Read more A man destroyed a $60 million US military plane at an Irish airport, prosecutors say