Santa Ana appears to be the first Orange County city to end its automated license plate reader contracts in response to community concerns over mass surveillance and data sharing.

Read more Short-term shuttle operators could fill Anaheim Resort transit gap

The City Council voted to terminate agreements with Flock Safety and Motorola Solutions Tuesday night, Nov. 17; the decision will power down 24 fixed Flock cameras, 24 fixed Motorola cameras and four Motorola mobile units rolled out over the past year.

The council’s decision was swift and took up little discussion, with council members directing City Manager Alvaro Nuñez to terminate the contracts outright. Several members urged that the cameras go dark immediately.

Santa Ana is among a growing number of OC cities rethinking the use of automated license plate readers following rising public apprehension over privacy and what agencies the data was being shared with.

In October, Fullerton’s leaders decided to pause the city’s use of Flock cameras for six months, but kept the contracts in place. Earlier this year, Costa Mesa leaders considered changes to the cameras’ use, but decided to keep the city’s program in place.

Santa Ana Councilmember Jessie Lopez said “residents were promised accountability” when the council first approved the purchase of the cameras in 2025, calling the council’s decision to terminate its contracts Tuesday night “the first step toward real accountability.”

It’s been more than a year since the Santa Ana Police Department rolled out the license plate reading cameras through the two contracts, with Santa Ana Police Chief Robert Rodriguez crediting the program’s investigative capabilities as one reason SAPD was able to identify and apprehend suspects in a variety of cases.

Read more Former Redlands mayor Pete Aguilar elected House Democratic party whip

Between April 1 and Sept. 30, the department credited the license plate readers with 30 vehicles found or identified, 20 arrests, three suspects identified and two missing people located. Stolen vehicles were the largest category, with 18 cases, followed by six firearm-related incidents.

Under the Flock Safety contract, 225 individuals, including patrol officers and investigative personnel, were authorized to access the program’s database and conduct searches, which averaged about 46 per day and totaled 17,829 by the end of September, city officials said. By comparison, records show the Motorola system had 140 authorized users, with searches averaging 57 per day and totaling 22,098.

A city staff report warned that Santa Ana cannot simply terminate either contract for convenience and that the city must identify a breach in writing and give the vendor 30 days to fix the issue if it wants to end the contract for cause. The city remains obligated to about $482,000 in scheduled payments, with roughly $131,000 left for Flock and $351,000 for Motorola, whose contract could trigger additional charges for early cancellation or require immediate payment of all remaining obligations if canceled.

Councilmember Thai Phan asked city staff to explore waiving or refunding the remaining fees, adding, “I don’t think at this time Flock or Motorola is looking for any additional negative press.”

The council also directed the city’s staff to research whether Santa Ana can legally ban the use of automated license plate reader on private property because they would currently remain despite the canceled city contracts.

City Attorney Sonia Carvalho told the council, “You’re giving us a research project that really is cutting-edge law,” pointing to developing California case law on how the state’s license plate reader rules, which impose disclosure and policy requirements on public agencies, interact with private entities’ use of the technology and related privacy issues.

Read more Florida pastor convicted of US charges related to assassination of Haitian President Jovenel Moïse

By admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *