Orange County has no shortage of choice pizza. But for Zach Scherer, co-founder of Chrysalis and Darkroom in Santa Ana, one specific style of pie was missing — namely, the 16-inch, Brooklyn pizza he grew fond of eating in New York City. Large, thin, foldable. So, he decided to make it himself.

Read more CIF-SS girls tennis finals: Previews of the Orange County matches Thursday

Scherer, along with fellow Darkroom chef and business partner Drew Adam and longtime friend Frank DeLoach (Playground, Tavern), opened Tifosi Pizza and Trattoria in Irvine on Wednesday, Nov. 11. Located at the Eighteen Main dining complex, the new Italian eatery takes over the former Monaco Italian Kitchen space.

Hungry? Sign up for The Eat Index, our weekly food newsletter, and find out where to eat and get the latest restaurant happenings in Orange County. Subscribe here.

The idea, as Scherer explained during a recent comped media preview, was to create a red-sauce pizzeria that combined East Coast sensibilities with a California approach to cooking.

“We have great pizzerias,” he said, namechecking such local favorites as Truly Pizza and Apizza Doho, But the particular New York-style pie he craved was harder to find. “I figured that if I liked it, maybe someone else would.”

The result is what the chefs call “New, New York” pizza, a variation on the familiar foldable slice that uses premium flours and a multiday fermentation process to produce a more flavorful crust.

But getting there took some doing.

  • The “WHT pizza” with crème fraîche, mozzarella, ricotta, caramelized onions,...
    The “WHT pizza” with crème fraîche, mozzarella, ricotta, caramelized onions, toasted sesame and black pepper. (Photo by Brock Keeling, Orange County Register/SCNG)
  • Pizzas at Tifosi Pizza and Trattoria in Irvine. (Photo by...
    Pizzas at Tifosi Pizza and Trattoria in Irvine. (Photo by Brock Keeling, Orange County Register/SCNG)
  • Whipped ricotta on grilled sourdough, part of the antipasti, at...
    Whipped ricotta on grilled sourdough, part of the antipasti, at Tifosi Pizza and Trattoria in Irvine. (Photo by Brock Keeling, Orange County Register/SCNG)
The “WHT pizza” with crème fraîche, mozzarella, ricotta, caramelized onions, toasted sesame and black pepper. (Photo by Brock Keeling, Orange County Register/SCNG)
Expand

The kitchen went through roughly two dozen dough recipes before settling on one. The finished product combines Petra 3, a stone-milled Italian wheat flour combined with hard American red wheat flour. The former contributes a subtle wheat flavor along with a little Neapolitan-style chew, while the latter lends the crust its characteristic crunch.

Pizza offerings include traditional cheese and pepperoni, along with more adventurous pies including a standout white with caramelized onions and sesame seeds and a Nonna pizza with vodka sauce, stracciatella, sausage and red onions. The chefs also insist that the crust should be treated as an ingredient in its own right, not merely an edible delivery system for sauce and cheese, so eat up. (Also of grave importance, you can get a side of ranch or hot honey, should you desire.)

Tifosi, Italian for “superfans,” isn’t strictly a pizza joint. The menu straddles traditional and modern Italian cooking, Italian-American red-sauce favorites and more inventive California-inspired fare.

Among the offerings are DeLoach’s grandmother’s meatballs and rigatoni with Sunday gravy. Other dishes, including coppa with Roman salsa macha, a lobster-studded gemelli with XO sauce, and seasonal crudos, veer further from the red-checkered-tablecloth playbook. Bistecca, branzino and chicken parmesan round out the secondi offerings.

  • Maltagliati al pesto with kale cashew pesto and whipped goat...
    Maltagliati al pesto with kale cashew pesto and whipped goat cheese. (Photo by Brock Keeling, Orange County Register/SCNG)
  • White ragu rollatini at Tifosi Pizza and Trattoria in Irvine....
    White ragu rollatini at Tifosi Pizza and Trattoria in Irvine. (Photo by Brock Keeling, Orange County Register/SCNG)
  • Rigatoni a la vodka at Tifosi Pizza and Trattoria in...
    Rigatoni a la vodka at Tifosi Pizza and Trattoria in Irvine. (Photo by Brock Keeling, Orange County Register/SCNG)
  • Lobster XO gemelli with XO sauce, scallions, toasted sesame and...
    Lobster XO gemelli with XO sauce, scallions, toasted sesame and lobster. (Photo by Brock Keeling, Orange County Register/SCNG)
Maltagliati al pesto with kale cashew pesto and whipped goat cheese. (Photo by Brock Keeling, Orange County Register/SCNG)
Expand

The pastas, in particular, are worth a visit alone, especially the rigatoni alla vodka, which uses a one-two umami punch of white miso and guanciale, along with the deliriously comforting rollatini with white ragu.

Read more Huntington Beach officials discuss preparations, resources ahead of king tides, El Niño storms

Homemade focaccia gets the same painstaking treatment as the pizza dough. Made with Italian whole-wheat flour, yeast, water and salt, it’s mixed by hand rather than subjected to an industrial mixer.

Lunch features pizza by the slice, whole pies, sandwiches and salads, while dinner expands into pastas, shared plates and larger entrees. Takeout and delivery will also be available at some point in the future.

  • Tifosi features banquette seating, orange and earthy hues and organic...
    Tifosi features banquette seating, orange and earthy hues and organic design. (Photo by Brock Keeling, Orange County Register/SCNG)
  • Tifosi’s design, created by the there chef-owners, is inspired by...
    Tifosi’s design, created by the there chef-owners, is inspired by the 1970s and Italian racing. (Photo by Brock Keeling, Orange County Register/SCNG)
  • Bartender David Sefo and beverage director Jenny Jimenez (Photo by...
    Bartender David Sefo and beverage director Jenny Jimenez (Photo by Brock Keeling, Orange County Register/SCNG)
  • Tifosi Pizza and Trattoria opened in Irvine on Wednesday, Nov....
    Tifosi Pizza and Trattoria opened in Irvine on Wednesday, Nov. 11. (Photo by Brock Keeling, Orange County Register/SCNG)
Tifosi features banquette seating, orange and earthy hues and organic design. (Photo by Brock Keeling, Orange County Register/SCNG)
Expand

As for the space, the three seasoned culinary minds took on the design themselves with Scherer leading the creative direction. After scooping up the former restaurant in August, they reworked the dining room, including its lighting, furnishings and color scheme. The result is a decidedly 1970s affair, but not the dated disco-ball-and-polyster variety. Inspired partly by Italian motorsports, the room favors burnt orange, mustard yellow, earthy browns and deep reds with rounded architectural details like cushioned banquettes, circular mirrors and a striking checkerboard-framed kitchen entrance.

Colorful skateboard art and vintage Italian artwork grace the walls, while sculptural pendant lights hover over gleaming tables. Also of note, two patios add to the restaurant’s indoor-outdoor feel.

“Darkroom is very moody,” said Scherer. “We wanted this to be moody, but moody and fun. So fun is the mood.”

Jenny Jimenez, whose resume includes Noble Ale Works, Recess and Darkroom, oversees the beverage program, which features a slew of Italian cocktails, seasonal creations and small-production wines.

For Scherer, Tifosi isn’t a departure from Darkroom but more of another outlet for the same chefs. “Same band members, but a different band project.”

Find it: 2000 Main St., Suite 300, Irvine, 949-316-4055, tifosipizzaandtrattoria.com

Read more Laguna Beach boys water polo set for CIF-SS semifinals after dramatic win

By admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *