Allegations of racist remarks and comments about sexual orientation lodged by Anaheim Mayor Ashleigh Aitken’s chief of staff had at least one City Council member calling for an investigation at Tuesday night’s meeting and several residents pushing for her resignation.
Read more Santa Ana Boys & Girls Club members have new space for great play
City spokesperson Mike Lyster confirmed Wednesday that a review is underway, though he said because it is a personnel issue he could not give more details.
In an article published Monday night, TimesOC reported on a mediation letter sent to Anaheim City Attorney Robert Fabela alleging Aitken referred to her chief of staff, Berenice Ballinas, by a racist term.
“On various occasions when Ms. Ballinas was forced to drive Mayor Aitkin (sic) home, Mayor Aitkin (sic) exclaimed that she did ‘not want her car driven by a dirty Mexican,’” Ballinas’s attorney Lawrence Lennemann said in the Sept. 11 letter, according to TimesOC.
Ballinas and Lennemann did not respond to requests for a copy of the letter sent to the city or for comment.
Lyster said he could not release the letter. The Orange County Register filed a Public Records Act request for it on Wednesday, but government entities have several days to respond to such requests.
Ballinas, who is Mexican American, has served as Aitken’s chief of staff since December 2022. Ballinas has also worked for several political campaigns and local and state officials.
Elected in 2022, Aitken, a Democrat, is the first voter-elected female mayor in Anaheim’s 165-year history (prior to the city’s transition to district elections, the mayor position rotated among councilmembers). Aitken is running for reelection, facing two challengers in her bid for a second, four-year term.
Aitken deferred requests for comment on Wednesday to a statement she made during Tuesday night’s City Council meeting.
“While I am limited in what I can say, I humbly ask people to take a moment and look at my record — the initiatives I have championed, the communities I have stood beside, my words and, most importantly, the values I have demonstrated through my actions,” Aitken said to a crowd of residents, some of whom called for her resignation.
“And of course, I will readily and truthfully participate in any way that I am asked going forward,” she added, before repeating the statement in Spanish.
Read more Facebook accused of deceiving users in New Mexico as trial over privacy scandal wraps up
District 6 Councilmember Natalie Meeks called for an investigation into the allegations, saying during Tuesday’s meeting that “if they are found to be true, then I would join with the community in asking for the mayor’s resignation, but she deserves, the situation deserves, an investigation.”
“I did not expect this at all,” Meeks later said of the allegations. “But it needs to be investigated and addressed. Whatever segment of our community, we need to respect everybody. I do respect every group in our community and in its diversity. And so we need to make sure that our council provides that same respect to everybody.”
Lyster did not say whether the investigation would be independently conducted, nor did he offer a timeline for results.
“We don’t have any additional details to share at this time,” he said Wednesday. “As many may understand, this touches on personnel matters that need to be addressed with sensitivity. A process is already in place and a review underway in the early stages. It is expected to be timely and thorough while respecting the process.”
“Beyond that, we want to be thoughtful of all involved and don’t have any additional updates to share at this time as the issues raised are reviewed,” he added.
The TimesOC story said the letter refers to June incidents at the Disneyland Resort’s private Club 33 and 1901 Lounge, saying, “Mayor Aitken’s conduct was so concerning that, as a result, the city’s own business partner, Disney, suspended a third party’s Club 33 membership and at least two Disney employees separately complained about the mayor’s conduct.”
The letter also alleges Aitken and former City Manager Jim Vanderpool made inappropriate inquiries into Ballinas’s perceived sexual orientation at other times between 2023 and 2026, “including myriad statements and insinuations that she is a lesbian, directly referring to her as a lesbian, pressuring her to admit that she was a lesbian, questioning of her romantic relationships, and comments directed at her guests and companions,” TimesOC reported.
Vanderpool joined Anaheim as its city manager in September 2020 and resigned in February amid reports that he attended a Lake Havasu retreat paid for by the Anaheim Chamber of Commerce early in his tenure with the city.
The trip’s guest list included some of Anaheim’s most influential, including the Chamber of Commerce’s leader at the time, who later became a key figure in a federal probe into City Hall corruption.
Read more Diane Keaton’s former Laguna Beach flip lists for $10.3M
Vanderpool did not immediately respond on Wednesday to requests for comment.