The first thing Tony Fasulo replaced at Cedar Creek Inn was the decades-old draft beer system. He wants new ice machines, too.

Read more A Somali American Uber driver was strangled and run over by a passenger, authorities say

“It’s got to be triple-filtered water,” he said, noting that ice made with filtered water is one of those small touches customers unconsciously appreciate — and some restaurants all too often overlook.

Fasulo and his business partner and wife, Dani, took over the longtime Brea restaurant this month. The couple acquired the Cedar Creek Inn brand, assumed the lease and kept the staff (yes, everyone still has a job), including chef Everardo Castañeda, who Fasulo said has worked there since day one.

Hungry? Sign up for The Eat Index, our weekly food newsletter, and find out where to eat and get the latest restaurant happenings in Orange County. Subscribe here.

Cedar Creek Inn is the Fasulos’ third business in Brea. The restaurateurs-slash-couple opened Old Brea Chop House downtown in 2019 and, most recently, Chef Cut Meat House, a butcher shop with a sandwich counter and a wine bar, in September. What’s more, the duo also plan on a steakhouse in Palm Desert’s tony El Paseo shopping district for early 2027.

The inception to purchase Cedar Creek Inn started during 2020 when Fasulo started looking for a restaurant with a patio, AT a time when the couple’s steakhouse had no outdoor dining. Chop House has about 30 tables and, according to Tony, limited parking. He had driven past Cedar Creek plenty of times and, eventually, asked its owners if they would ever consider selling the 27-year old place.

  • Old Fashioned cocktail from the temporary takeout menu at Old...
    Old Fashioned cocktail from the temporary takeout menu at Old Brea Chop House in Brea (Photo by Brad A. Johnson, Orange County Register/SCNG)
  • Owners Tony Fasulo and his wife Dani at the Old...
    Owners Tony Fasulo and his wife Dani at the Old Brea Chop House in Brea on Thursday, November 7, 2019. This brand new steak house is on the Register’s Top 10 list of the restaurants foodies craved to read about most in 2019. (Photo by Paul Rodriguez, Contributing Photographer)
  • The chef cut tomahawk ribeye steak at The Old Brea...
    The chef cut tomahawk ribeye steak at The Old Brea Chop House in Brea on Thursday, November 7, 2019. (Photo by Paul Rodriguez, Contributing Photographer)
Old Fashioned cocktail from the temporary takeout menu at Old Brea Chop House in Brea (Photo by Brad A. Johnson, Orange County Register/SCNG)
Expand

“I thought I could turn that place into something awesome,” Fasulo said.

Richard and Nancy Ayres opened the first Cedar Creek Inn in Lake Arrowhead in 1976 and followed two decades later with the Brea location in 1999. When he tells people about the deal, effectively nabbing one of the city’s most storied eateries, Fasulo hears about the birthdays, proms and anniversaries they celebrated there.

Of course, the Coconut Supreme Cake comes up, too.

“We’re going to leave probably 90% of the menu alone,” he revealed. That includes the lauded coconut cake. But he wants the kitchen to make its own in-house chicken pot pies, short ribs, soups and stocks. He brings up Houston’s as a model for the kind of restaurant he wants Cedar Creek to become, somewhere a family could go for dinner once or twice a week.

Fasulo said the first year at Cedar Creek will focus on the food, service and equipment, down to the air conditioning. Dani will help lead service training, drawing on her time opening restaurants and training staff at Morton’s The Steakhouse. The couple met at the chain, where Tony spent roughly two decades and helped open steakhouses in Atlantic City and Mexico City, among other cities.

The idea for Chef Cut Meat House, now open at 415. S. Associated Road, goes back to the pandemic. With the steakhouse dining room closed and customers taking up backyard grilling and hobby meat smoking, the Fasulos started selling steaks to cook at home. There were takeout deals, too. Fasulo remembers selling two sandwiches, a salad and a bottle of wine for $25 to $30.

Read more DMV restricts Waymo from operating or testing driverless vehicles on all California freeways

ALSO READ: 6 new Orange County restaurants to put on your radar

There was the matter, too, of the steakhouse’s walk-in. “We had to replace the floors twice because there was so much meat in the cooler,” he said. The weight had buckled the floor. And limited storage meant frequent deliveries from New Jersey meat supplier Pat LaFrieda. Fasulo put the freight at about $1,000 a month. A butcher shop, he thought, would give them room to cut and store meat.

“I’m an OC kid,” said Fasulo, 60, who started working in restaurants at 16, making tiramisu and cannoli. When he lived in Atlantic City, he and Dani would nosh on cheesesteaks or peppers-and-egg sandwiches on the Boardwalk. Fasulo made frequent trips to Philadelphia for the state’s famous titular sandwiches.

“They have the best sandwiches on planet Earth,” he said of the city of Brotherly Love and New Jersey. “I wanted to bring that to Orange County.”

His preferred pick at Chef Cut for newbies is the $22 Wagyu cheesesteak, with a thinly sliced beef seared on a plancha, onions and a seeded roll he says he flies in from Philadelphia. The shop bakes focaccia for such standouts like the mortadella with stracciatella and pistachio pesto. It also makes its own black-and-white cookies, the cake-like NYC deli staple, and toffee chocolate chip cookies crowned with a sprinkling of salt.

The space has about 20 seats, fewer than he would like. “They don’t want to leave,” he said of customers who settle in with a sandwich and glass of wine.

Meanwhile, back east (aka Riverside County), Palm Desert is familiar territory for Fasulo, who ran restaurants in the Coachella Valley in the early 1990s. In 2025, he bought the former Cuistot property at 72595 El Paseo Drive, a onetime French restaurant with a patio and its own parking. The Fasulos hope to open El Paseo Chop House, replete with a piano bar and its own distinct vibe, by the end of March 2027.

“This will be a legacy restaurant that I could own and hand down to generations,” he said.

Read more Proposal ends in heartbreak when 4-carat ring swept away in waves

By admin

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *